St. Augustine, Florida, is a historic city with a delicious food scene that’s as rich as its past. From hidden gems to tourist hotspots with serious street cred, this is the ultimate St. Augustine food crawl to eat like a local. Buckle up, bring your appetite, and let’s hit six must-visit spots where flavor reigns supreme.
Did you know, that St. Augustine, the nation’s oldest city, has some of the best local cuisine?! Who knew, RIGHT?! Boasting different pub crawls, wine tastings, and tasting tours, they’re a great way to get your feet wet. Not to mention…some of the best chef’s call this small town home.
Why a St. Augustine food crawl?!
Simple. WE LOVE FOOD. It’s such a fun way to explore a new area and meet new friends!
By definition, a food crawl is a series of visits to multiple restaurants or food places in a specific area.
A slice of pizza, the perfect chocolate, or savoring the UFO from A1A Burrito Works…perfect for adventuring new towns with a rich history! Food crawls offer an unforgettable experience while enjoying St. Augustine’s history.
The goal is to sample the local food and culture. What started years ago allowed our family to share and try out all the gourmet shops and have the PERFECT food experience.
Planning a visit to America’s oldest city?! We think you’ll LOVE to explore Florida’s historic coast with our favorite hidden gems and off-the-beaten path with our favorite food and best places to WANDER!
- DISCOVER WASHINGTON OAKS: ST. AUGUSTINE’S HIDDEN GEM
- EXPLORE FALL CAMPING AT ANASTASIA STATE PARK, FLORIDA
- ST, AUGUSTINE NIGHTS OF LIGHTS CHRISTMAS IN FLORIDA
- HOW TO HAVE THE PERFECT COUPLE’S DAY IN ST. AUGUSTINE
- FLORIDA’S OFF-THE-BEATEN-PATH GUIDE TO ST. AUGUSTINE
- BLUE HEN CAFE: ST. AUGUSTINE’S BEST BREAKFAST SPOT
- ST. AUGUSTINE HIDDEN GEM RESTAURANT WITH A VIEW
Experience St. Augustine With Private Group Tours.
Take a guided culinary tour and discover St. Augustine’s history while drinking exquisite wines and feasting throughout this ancient city. Your expert guide will share the perfect wine pairings and best dishes.
These tours are a lot of fun and perfect for small groups. The knowledgeable guides will not only entertain you with fun St. Augustine history and culinary heritage but will fill your bellies with delicious food!
PRO TIP: Allow for a three-hour tour and book early, especially during the holiday season. Perfect for bachelorette parties, couples, families, and girls and guy weekends.
But, if you prefer to explore on your own and enjoy a little local flavor, then grab your comfortable walking shoes and your appetite. Let US be your tour guide as we hit the local hot spots while drinking in all the spectacular and spooky St. Augustine history.
Start Sweet at The Hyppo.
No food crawl should begin without a refreshing palate cleanser, and the perfect starting point is The Hyppo. Located in the historic district Specializing in gourmet ice pops, this local favorite serves up bold flavors crafted from fresh fruit and high-quality ingredients.
Try a unique combo like Mango Habanero or Pineapple Cilantro for a sweet-meets-spicy kick. Their handcrafted pops are perfect for cooling down in the Florida heat while you stroll through the historic streets.
What do we love?! ALL THE FLAVORS! However…the strawberry bourbon and the Datil pineapple dipped in chocolate are our favs!
PRO TIP: Ask to have your delicious crafted popsicle dipped in gourmet melted chocolate. It’s AMAZING. You’re welcome!
Find them at: 70 Saint George Street, Saint Augustine, FL 32084 | 904-377-8494
Get Cheesy at Sarbez.
Next up, let’s embrace gooey, melty perfection at Sarbez, a quirky dive bar that meets grilled cheese haven. Whether you opt for a classic cheddar melt or go wild with toppings like bacon jam, apples, and brie, you can’t go wrong.
Pair your sandwich with one of their many craft beers on tap and challenge your friends to a game of arcade classics in the back room. This spot is a must for casual comfort food lovers.
Find them at: 115 Anastasia Blvd., Saint Augustine, Fl 32080 | 904-342-0632
Savor a Slice at Pizza Time.
A St. Augustine food crawl isn’t complete without a visit to Pizza Time, consistently ranked as one of the best pizzerias in the country. Their New York-style slices are legendary, with crispy-yet-chewy crusts and perfectly balanced sauce.
The line often spills out the door, but trust us—it’s worth the wait. Grab a slice of the white pizza or the famous Margherita, and don’t forget a side of garlic knots for good measure.
Find them at: 124 St George St, Saint Augustine, Florida 32084 | 904-819-0133
Classy Cocktails at the Tini Martini Bar.
Time for a break? Head over to the Tini Martini Bar at the Casablanca Inn for a sophisticated sip.
Nestled in a charming historic inn, this cozy bar serves some of the best-handcrafted martinis in town. Whether you go for a dirty martini or something fruity like their raspberry lemon drop, this spot offers the perfect ambiance to relax and take in the scenic bayfront views.
A little elegance in the middle of your food crawl never hurt anyone!
PRO TIP: Have your ID handy because you are pre-carded before being allowed to be sat.
Find them at: 24 Avenida Menendez, St. Augustine, FL 32084 Phone: 904- 829-0929
Fresh Catches at Catch 27.
After a cocktail interlude, it’s time for some fresh Florida seafood at Catch 27. This beloved eatery is all about locally sourced ingredients and sustainable seafood.
Go for the blackened fish tacos, shrimp, and grits, or their famous cast-iron seared fish of the day. The flavors are fresh, the atmosphere is cozy, and the menu truly tastes Florida’s coastal bounty.
PRO TIP: Plan a reservation around dusk. The lighting is gorgeous and the atmosphere is festive!
Find them at: 40 Charlotte Street, St. Augustine, Fl | 904- 298-6786
End on a Sweet Note at Claude’s Chocolate.
No food adventure is complete without dessert, and Claude’s Chocolate is the perfect final stop. This artisanal chocolate shop offers handcrafted truffles, gourmet chocolate bars, and indulgent hot cocoa for a rich, satisfying ending.
Try their sea salt caramel truffle or dark chocolate raspberry ganache to experience pure chocolate bliss.
Find them at: 6 Granada Street, St. Augustine, FL, 32084 | 904-808-8395
Bonus Tips for Your St. Augustine Food Crawl:
- Go Hungry – This itinerary is packed with flavor, so pace yourself and bring a big appetite.
- Walk Between Stops – Luckily, most of these eateries are within walking distance, allowing you to explore St. Augustine’s historic charm while burning off a few calories.
- Visit on a Weekday – If possible, avoid peak weekend crowds for a smoother experience.
- Bring Cash – Some smaller spots appreciate cash payments, and it’s always good to have some on hand.
- Try it in Courses- Pick which “course” to try at each location!
- Drink Plenty of Water- In between stops, chug plenty of water. St. Augustine stays pretty toasty year-round so staying hydrated is key.
Ready to Do a St. Augustine Food Crawl & Feast Like a Local?!
A food crawl through St. Augustine is the best way to eat like a local, one delicious stop at a time. Whether you’re a first-time visitor or a seasoned foodie, this lineup will have your taste buds thanking you. Ready to dig in? Let the ultimate food adventure begin! Happy Wandering!
Thanks for stopping by! "Hulasquatch" is the ultimate blend of adventure and chill! Part wild explorer, part laid-back Floridian, and always ready to hula through life’s adventures. Come along for the adventure as we explore Florida & beyond. Discovering off-the-beaten-path destinations, testing out cool gear, eating & creating fantastic food along the way. Happy wandering!
Yes! I am ready for a St. Augustine food crawl, now that you got me primed and my juices flowing! Wished it wasn’t so far away. I thoroughly enjoyed your tour here and will bookmark this in case I ever do get to go!
Thanks so much Heidi! I’m glad you got the fun vibe through the post!
I love how you think included all little bit of everything into the St. Augustine food crawl. A place for drinks, main courses, and dessert.
Thank you! St. Augustine is one of the best places to enjoy all the great food and history!
St Augustine has such an amazing food scene. We loved Hyppo and can’t wait to go back.
Sarah let us know when come down & we will food crawl St. Augustine!😁
I’ve said it once, and I’ll say it again: I am SO sad I did not have your blog when we lived in Florida and often visited St. Augustine!!! Such a great post, so informative and fun!
Thanks, Makenzie! Come hang out with us anytime & we so appreciate your love for our blig!😁
Now I’m hungry! Thanks for all the delicious info!
You are so welcome!😁
Makes me want to visit St. Augustine next!! Thanks for sharing 🙂
You’ll love St. Augustine!
What great recommendations! We will have to check them out when we’re in that area!
Ooh, I love this! Such a fun idea with lots of great places to try! Now I can’t wait to get back to St. Augustine! Thanks for sharing!
LOVE a good food crawl, just another reason to visit!